No metaphor is perfect but some are enough to get us started in understanding St. Thomas’s distinction between essence (what a thing is) and existence (the fact that a thing is). The first comes from Barry Miller, who asks us to think of “the homely analogy of a block of butter that has been cut into a number of parts. Each piece of butter has a different surface or bound. A peculiar thing about bounds is that, although they are real enough, they themselves are totally devoid of thickness: they are not to be mistaken for an enveloping film whether of butter or of any other material whatsoever. Despite their ontological poverty, however, they do have a genuine function, for they serve to distinguish every block from every other block. In that sense they can be said to individuate the blocks they bound.”
Share this post
Starting Metaphors for the Essence/Existence…
Share this post
No metaphor is perfect but some are enough to get us started in understanding St. Thomas’s distinction between essence (what a thing is) and existence (the fact that a thing is). The first comes from Barry Miller, who asks us to think of “the homely analogy of a block of butter that has been cut into a number of parts. Each piece of butter has a different surface or bound. A peculiar thing about bounds is that, although they are real enough, they themselves are totally devoid of thickness: they are not to be mistaken for an enveloping film whether of butter or of any other material whatsoever. Despite their ontological poverty, however, they do have a genuine function, for they serve to distinguish every block from every other block. In that sense they can be said to individuate the blocks they bound.”