In response to the problem of evil Thomists have suggested that God “aims” at goods that logically depend upon suffering — for example, compassion — in response to why God didn’t just make us “all good, all the time.” In other words, to make some goods actual — mercy, the incarnation, etc — entails (at least the permission) of evil. However, this invites the charge that God is willing immoral means to some good end: essentially, God is a cosmic utilitarian.
Share this post
Evil, God, and Logically Dependent Goods
Share this post
In response to the problem of evil Thomists have suggested that God “aims” at goods that logically depend upon suffering — for example, compassion — in response to why God didn’t just make us “all good, all the time.” In other words, to make some goods actual — mercy, the incarnation, etc — entails (at least the permission) of evil. However, this invites the charge that God is willing immoral means to some good end: essentially, God is a cosmic utilitarian.